Family Voices — Hallie’s Story
Hallie was trapped between her mattress and crib side, rescued by her mother. She was six months old.
Submitted by her mother
“At around six months of age, or thereabouts, I put my daughter in her crib to play while I put her clean clothes in her dresser. To my horror, I watched her arm slide down the corner of her bed up to her shoulder. She had become wedged and trapped face down.
My daughter’s “standard size” crib mattress was too small for her “standard size” crib. Upon further inspection, her mattress was a good 3”-4” shorter than the interior of her crib. I bought the Graco “Lauren” crib and a Kolcraft mattress. Graco would not take an incident report, nor would they talk to me about this problem. I was referred to the manufacturer, LaJobi. LaJobi’s representative agreed to send me a new mattress at no charge. When I asked if this was a common problem, he told me, yes, it was fairly common and they had replaced mattresses for other customers. But most surprising was his explanation of why the “standard size” mattress did not fit the “standard size” crib correctly. There is no industry standard for measuring crib mattresses. In addition, the clips that held the drop rail in place, had also failed to operate correctly. Those were replaced with the new mattress.
I begged the retailer, Target, to include mattress recommendations in their product descriptions, to no avail. Had I had better information, I would have made a wiser choice. Very often nursery items are purchased by family members, who otherwise, would not know the dangers these unregulated products pose.”
What’s Happened Since Hallie’s Incident?
In 2008, Simmons Kids recalled 20,000 crib mattresses because they are smaller than the required 27 1/4 inch width required by law. This can cause a gap which can entrap a child. The company has one report of an entrapment; the parent was able to free the child.
In 2016 alone, there were 11,300 emergency room treated injuries that were related to cribs/matresses, according to a CPSC report. According to the same report, about 10% of the 109 crib-related deaths that occured between 2012-2014 were related to ill-fitting mattresses. Historically, the majority of crib-related deaths are usually due to a cluttered sleep space resulting in asphyxiation.
In 2016 a new ASTM standard went into effect which addressed the growing need to address safety requirements for cribs and crib mattresses. Topics covered in the standard include the gap between a mattress and crib rails, the height of a crib from the top of a mattress and mattress thickness. According to ASTM, the standard establishes design requirements, testing requirements and methods, and requirements for labeling for full-size and non-full-size crib mattresses.
How You Can Take Action
To take action and help prevent further incidents, injuries, and deaths,
there are a number of things you can do:
- Any time you buy a play yard or portable crib, check that the manufacture date is after February 28th, 2013 to make sure that it meets the strong standards set by CPSC.
- Register all infant and toddler durable products so you can be alerted to recalls.
- Check all sleep environments like cribs and other children’s products for recalls by visiting CPSC.gov and typing searching the recall database.
- Register for KID’s monthly email alert to stay up-to-date on all children’s product recalls and receive safety tips and information.
More Information on Cribs
Although mandatory standards exist for cribs, only recently has an effort been made to strengthen those standards and require testing and verification of new cribs. Because of these standards, all cribs must include proper assembly instructions and diagrams as well as cautionary and warning labels as required by federal law.
More information on Safe Sleep
A safe sleep environment is the one place parents and caregivers can place an infant and know they will be safe, even as the parent sleeps or attends to other things. Infants sleep safest following the ABC’s of safe sleep&emdash;Alone, on their Back and in a Crib, bassinet or play yard that meets federal standards and hasn’t been recalled. AAP also recommends babies sleep on a flat surface and unrestrained. Nothing should be in the crib except a firm mattress with a tight-fitting sheet.
View our safe sleep video to learn more about how to keep your baby safe while sleeping.